Indo pak relations and Indian muslims.
Was watching an old interview of Modi on ndtv wherein shekar gupta asked a question that is still stuck in my mind.The q is' isn't good relations between India and pak a necessity for Indian Muslims'?
The very first thought that came up in my mind was that the journo was unabashedly doubting the patriotism and insulting Muslims living in various parts of India by posing such a q.
On a ruminating over the controversial q i reasoned that since generally journo's and politicians have a finger on things ,maybe he had guaged the innermost and secret desire of every Muslim in India that they would feel more secure in muslim majority Pak than in Hindu India.Which means that he assumes that if indo pak realtions become good it would make it easy for any muslim wanting to migrate to Pak.As per his divination there should be torrent of such migrations. Fine ,then will pak be willing to allow such a flow to swamp it?
What he is indirectly implying is that Muslims are not secure or comfortable in India and if given a chance they will all gladly leave this for the neighbouring one.Then why only to pak why not to e.pak--Bangladesh--another neighbouring muslim majority country?.
Then why is the largest migration --illegal-- in the world as per toi is from Muslim bangaladesh to Hindu India.Why aren't they all moving to pak instead? Instead of from one safe muslim country to another they are all moving into 'insecure' India .Will Pak allow all these millions of bangladeshis into their country if a passage and gateway is arranged for all of them, if incredibly our politicians reform over a period of time ?
Now back to the bizarre q.May be the generation during and immediately after the partition were enamoured of pak.But now in all probability mus, specially from south would rather migrate to Dubai or earn a living there than in pak just as Hindu would also prefer to earn in Dubhe or migrate to u.s rather to a very much Hindu neighbouring Nepal.
I don't think that indian muslims destiny is in any way connected with the relations between india and pak.It is in here. It is in impartial enforcement of law and in economic development just like it is for any other citizen of india.
written on 21.9.13.4pm
The very first thought that came up in my mind was that the journo was unabashedly doubting the patriotism and insulting Muslims living in various parts of India by posing such a q.
On a ruminating over the controversial q i reasoned that since generally journo's and politicians have a finger on things ,maybe he had guaged the innermost and secret desire of every Muslim in India that they would feel more secure in muslim majority Pak than in Hindu India.Which means that he assumes that if indo pak realtions become good it would make it easy for any muslim wanting to migrate to Pak.As per his divination there should be torrent of such migrations. Fine ,then will pak be willing to allow such a flow to swamp it?
What he is indirectly implying is that Muslims are not secure or comfortable in India and if given a chance they will all gladly leave this for the neighbouring one.Then why only to pak why not to e.pak--Bangladesh--another neighbouring muslim majority country?.
Then why is the largest migration --illegal-- in the world as per toi is from Muslim bangaladesh to Hindu India.Why aren't they all moving to pak instead? Instead of from one safe muslim country to another they are all moving into 'insecure' India .Will Pak allow all these millions of bangladeshis into their country if a passage and gateway is arranged for all of them, if incredibly our politicians reform over a period of time ?
Now back to the bizarre q.May be the generation during and immediately after the partition were enamoured of pak.But now in all probability mus, specially from south would rather migrate to Dubai or earn a living there than in pak just as Hindu would also prefer to earn in Dubhe or migrate to u.s rather to a very much Hindu neighbouring Nepal.
I don't think that indian muslims destiny is in any way connected with the relations between india and pak.It is in here. It is in impartial enforcement of law and in economic development just like it is for any other citizen of india.
written on 21.9.13.4pm
Labels: comment on tv anchors q
posted by K.C. Sujata at
12:54 AM
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home